What Romans 9:4 really means: Chosen by God

The Privileged Position of Israel

Paul writes Romans 9 with deep sorrow, because even though the Israelites were chosen by God and given incredible blessings, many have not believed in Jesus as the Messiah.

He begins by identifying strongly with them - after all, he too is an Israelite, as he says in Acts 22:3: 'I am indeed a Jew, born in Tarsus in Cilicia, but brought up in this city, educated at the feet of Gamaliel, strictly according to the law of our ancestors, being zealous for God just as all of you are today.' These people had the unique privilege of being adopted as God’s children, experiencing His glory in the tabernacle and temple, receiving the covenants that promised blessing to the world, hearing God’s law given at Mount Sinai, and carrying the true form of worship. They were also the recipients of God’s promises, like the one in Genesis 12:3 that through Abraham’s family all nations would be blessed.

Yet despite all these advantages, many Israelites rejected Jesus - and Paul’s heart breaks over that reality, setting up his deeper discussion of how God’s plan still moves forward through faith.

The Weight of God's Gifts to Israel

Each blessing listed in Romans 9:4 is a historical fact and a sacred thread showing how God shaped Israel to reflect His character and purpose to the world.

Adoption means God chose Israel as His special people, calling them 'my firstborn son' in Exodus 4:22 - a deep family bond, not based on their goodness but on His love. The glory refers to God’s visible presence, like the cloud that filled the tabernacle in Exodus 16:7, showing He lived among them in power and holiness. The covenants - like the one with Abraham in Genesis 15, where God promised land, descendants, and blessing for all nations - were sacred agreements that set Israel apart. The law given at Mount Sinai in Exodus 19 - 20 was not merely rules. It was God’s personal instruction for how His holy people should live, directly tied to worship that honored Him rightly.

These promises were not empty words. They formed the foundation of Israel’s identity. Genesis 12:2-3 says God would bless Abraham so that 'in you all the families of the earth shall be blessed' - a promise that reached far beyond Israel itself. Yet Paul is careful not to let these privileges be misunderstood as automatic salvation. Being chosen didn’t mean every Israelite would inherit the promise, as later verses in Romans 9 make clear - God’s choice moves according to His mercy, not human effort.

This leads directly into Paul’s next point: if being born an Israelite isn’t enough, then how does God decide who counts as His true people? That question opens the door to his deeper discussion of election and mercy in Romans 9:6-24.

Not All Israel Are Truly God's People

Even though Israel as a nation had incredible privileges, Paul makes clear that not every descendant of Abraham is part of God’s true family - being part of the promise depends on faith, not bloodline.

In Romans 9:6-8, Paul explains that God’s word hasn’t failed, because not everyone born into Israel is truly part of Israel. He quotes Scripture to show that only the children of the promise are counted as Abraham’s true descendants - like Isaac, not Ishmael - proving that God’s choice is based on His purpose, not human birth. This idea is echoed in Galatians 3:7, which says, 'Know then that it is those who have faith who are the children of Abraham.'

From the beginning, God’s people were defined by trust in Him rather than ancestry, opening the door for Gentiles to be included through faith in Jesus, the true heir of Abraham’s promise.

From Israel's Privileges to the World's Hope

Romans 9:4 is more than a list of ancient blessings; it serves as a bridge between God’s promises to Israel and His plan to bring salvation to all nations through Christ.

The adoption, glory, covenants, law, worship, and promises all point forward to Jesus. When John writes in John 1:14, 'The Word became flesh and dwelt among us, and we have seen his glory, full of grace and truth,' he shows that Jesus is the fulfillment of Israel’s story - God’s glory now lives among us not in a tabernacle, but in a person. The law and worship pointed to Him, and the promises made to Abraham in Genesis 12 and 17 find their yes in Christ.

Even though Israel had these privileges, Ephesians 2:11-13 reminds us that without Christ, both Jews and Gentiles were once 'without hope and without God in the world.' But now, through faith in Jesus, Gentiles are 'no longer strangers and foreigners, but fellow citizens with the saints and members of God’s household.' This means the wall between people groups is broken down - not because Israel’s role was erased, but because God’s promise was always meant to include the nations. The covenants were not the end. They were the path to blessing for all families on earth.

So today, when we gather as a church, we don’t boast in heritage or tradition alone - we welcome everyone, knowing that faith in Christ makes us true children of Abraham. Our communities should reflect this: no favoritism, no pride in the past, but joyful inclusion of all who trust Jesus. And as we live this out, we become living proof that God’s ancient promises are still shaping the world today - leading us into the next truth Paul unfolds: how God’s mercy extends to all who believe.

Application