What John 19:31-37 really means: Fulfilling Every Promise

The Urgency of Preparation Day

To understand why the Jewish leaders rushed to remove the bodies before sunset, we need to grasp the importance of the day they were on.

It was the day of Preparation, the day before the Sabbath, and this Sabbath was no ordinary one - it was a ‘high day,’ likely tied to the Passover festival, making it especially sacred. According to Jewish custom, no work could be done on the Sabbath, and leaving a body hanging on a cross would have been seen as defiling the land, so Deuteronomy 21:23 says, 'You must not leave the body hanging on the pole overnight; be sure to bury it the same day, because anyone who is hung on a pole is under God’s curse.' To avoid breaking this law, the leaders asked Pilate to have the legs of those crucified broken, a brutal way to speed up death so the bodies could be taken down before evening.

This moment was part of God’s larger plan. The timing and treatment of Jesus’ body fulfilled Scripture exactly as promised, going beyond mere religious rules.

The Fulfillment of Scripture in Jesus' Death: Unbroken Bones and Pierced Side

Every detail of Jesus’ crucifixion was not left to chance, but fulfilled ancient Scriptures in ways that reveal His identity as the long-awaited Savior.

The Gospel writer highlights that Jesus’ legs were not broken, fulfilling the command in Exodus 12:46 about the Passover lamb: 'You must not break any of its bones,' a rule later echoed in Psalm 34:20: 'He protects all his bones; not one of them is broken.' In Jewish tradition, the Passover lamb was a symbol of deliverance - its blood saved households from death in Egypt, and now Jesus, as the true Lamb of God, offers salvation through His sacrifice. That His bones remained unbroken was not merely a coincidence. It marked Him as the perfect, divinely appointed sacrifice. This detail, recorded only in John, underscores that Jesus fulfills the deepest layers of Israel’s story.

At the same time, one of the soldiers pierced Jesus’ side, and John notes that 'immediately blood and water came out.' Medically, this likely indicates that Jesus had died from a combination of severe trauma and possibly fluid buildup around the heart or in the lungs, a detail that adds historical credibility to the account. John is pointing to meaning, not merely giving a medical report. This act fulfills Zechariah 12:10: 'And they will look on me, the one they have pierced, and they will mourn for him as one mourns for an only child.' Here, God speaks in the first person, promising that one day Israel will grieve over the One they rejected - Jesus, the pierced Messiah. John wants us to see that even in death, Jesus is being revealed as both sacrificed Lamb and divine Lord.

These fulfilled prophecies demonstrate God's work through every act of cruelty to accomplish His redemptive plan. They are not merely proof texts. The unbroken bones declare His perfection. The pierced side opens the way for belief.

Jesus was not just another victim of crucifixion - His death was shaped by prophecy, proving He is the true Passover Lamb and the promised Messiah.

This moment of fulfillment sets the stage for what comes next: the hope of resurrection, not merely burial.

Believe: The Purpose of the Pierced Side

John makes the purpose of this whole account clear: 'These things happened so that you also may believe.'

He points to the eyewitness testimony of the soldier who saw blood and water flow from Jesus’ side, not to impress us with details, but to ground our faith in real events that fulfill God’s promises. This is not a myth or a moral tale - it’s a call to trust that Jesus is who He said He is.

John doesn’t just want us to know what happened - he wants us to believe it.

The story fits John’s gospel perfectly, where belief in Jesus as the Son of God leads to life (John 20:31). Now, the pierced side of Christ invites us to look on Him, mourn our sin, and find hope.

Jesus as the True Passover Lamb: Fulfilling the Feast and Shaping the Church

John’s emphasis on fulfilled Scripture in Jesus’ crucifixion directly ties Him to the Passover, showing He is the long-awaited fulfillment of Israel’s most sacred feast, rather than merely a martyr.

Just as the Passover lamb in Exodus 12:46 was to have no broken bones - a sign of its perfection - Jesus’ unbroken body marks Him as the true Lamb whose blood delivers God’s people from death. This connection is deepened in 1 Corinthians 5:7, where Paul writes, 'For Christ, our Passover lamb, has been sacrificed,' showing that early Christians saw Jesus’ death not as a tragedy, but as the moment the old symbols gave way to the real thing.

Jesus didn’t just die during Passover - He became the reality the feast had pointed to for centuries.

This fulfillment doesn’t end in the past - it shapes how believers understand their identity, gathered not around a temple meal, but around the crucified and risen Lord.

Application