Unpacking Jeremiah 23:28: Wheat vs Straw

Understanding the Prophets in a Time of Deception

God speaks through Jeremiah to a nation flooded with false prophets who claimed divine messages through dreams, while ignoring His true word.

Jeremiah 23:1-22 sets the scene: Judah’s leaders and prophets had led God’s people astray, so judgment was coming. These false prophets were giving comforting visions of peace and safety, but they were lies - like straw that looks like wheat from a distance but offers no real nourishment. God asks, “What has straw in common with wheat?” to show how utterly different His true word is from human inventions.

God’s word brings life and truth; anything else, no matter how spiritual it sounds, is empty if it’s not from Him.

Straw and Wheat: Telling the Difference Between False and True Messages

The image of straw versus wheat in Jeremiah 23:28 exposes the dangerous gap between human imagination and divine truth.

Straw looks light and fluffy, maybe even similar to wheat from afar, but it has no value when you’re hungry. Likewise, dreams and visions from false prophets might sound spiritual, but they don’t nourish the soul. God says, 'Let the prophet who has a dream tell the dream, but let him who has my word speak my word faithfully,' making it clear that not every spiritual-sounding message is from Him. He’s not banning dreams altogether - He used dreams Himself at times - but He’s demanding that His actual word takes priority. Deuteronomy 18:20-22 says a true prophet must speak what God actually says, and if their predictions fail, they’re exposed. Ezekiel 13:2-3 also condemns prophets who follow their own spirits instead of hearing God’s word, like Jeremiah’s false prophets.

True prophecy is not about dramatic visions or predicting the future to impress people; it is about faithfulness to God’s revealed word. The people needed to hear not what made them feel safe, but what would bring them back to God’s truth, even if it was hard. Zechariah 10:2 echoes this, saying idols and false dreamers speak 'empty things,' leading people astray like sheep without a shepherd - showing this problem didn’t end with Jeremiah.

What has straw in common with wheat? declares the Lord.

By asking, 'What has straw in common with wheat?' God uses a simple farming image to make a powerful point: no matter how much you mix them, straw can’t feed you, and no amount of spiritual talk can replace His living word. This contrast prepares us for the promise in Jeremiah 23:29: “Is not my word like fire, and like a hammer that breaks the rock in pieces?”' - showing that God’s message is active, powerful, and life-changing.

Faithfully Speaking God's Word: From Jeremiah to Jesus

The call to speak God’s word faithfully points forward to the one true Prophet who would finally speak God’s word perfectly: Jesus.

Jesus is the ultimate contrast to the false prophets. While they spoke dreams and empty words, Jesus said, 'My teaching is not my own, but comes from the one who sent me' (John 7:16), showing He spoke only what the Father gave Him. In fact, Jesus fulfills Jeremiah’s promise of a true shepherd and true prophet - Jeremiah 23:5 had foretold a righteous Branch from David’s line, and Jesus is that promised King who leads with wisdom and truth.

Jesus’ words bring eternal life - “The words I have spoken to you are spirit and life” (John 6:63) - proving He is the living Word that no human vision or dream could replace.

Wheat Among the Weeds: How Jeremiah’s Warning Points to God’s Final Harvest

Jeremiah’s question about straw and wheat echoes through the whole Bible, pointing to a final day when God will fully separate what is true from what is empty.

Jesus picks up this theme in the parable of the wheat and weeds, where He says the kingdom of heaven is like a farmer who lets both grow together until the harvest, because pulling up the weeds might uproot the wheat too - so God waits, giving time for repentance. But He promises a day is coming when the weeds will be gathered and burned, and the righteous will shine like the sun in their Father’s kingdom. This shows that while truth and falsehood still mix in our world, like straw tangled with wheat, God is not blind to the difference and will one day set all things right.

That final separation is still ahead of us, which means we live in a time where dreams, opinions, and spiritual-sounding noise still crowd out God’s true word.

Jesus warns that false prophets come in sheep’s clothing but are ravenous wolves (Matthew 7:15). Peter says false teachers will secretly bring in destructive beliefs, even denying the Master who bought them (2 Peter 2:1‑3). John urges us to test every spirit because many false prophets have gone out into the world (1 John 4:1). Paul also speaks of building on the foundation of Christ with gold, silver, and precious stones - or with wood, hay, and straw - and warns that each person’s work will be revealed by fire on the day of judgment (1 Corinthians 3:12). These images all trace back to Jeremiah’s contrast: one thing lasts and feeds, the other burns and vanishes.

What has straw in common with wheat? declares the Lord.

Yet we have hope, because the same God who spoke through Jeremiah has spoken fully in His Son, Jesus, who is the Word made flesh (John 1:14), and one day every lie will be silenced. Until then, we hold fast to His word, trusting that the final harvest is coming - when the wheat will be gathered into God’s barn, and straw will be no more.

Application