What Genesis 25:22-23 really means: Two Nations, One Womb

Context of the Divine Promise and a Mother's Question

This moment with Rebekah echoes earlier struggles in the story of God’s people, especially the long wait for a child that Isaac and Rebekah endured, a struggle Abraham and Sarah also faced.

Rebekah was barren at first, but Isaac prayed and God answered, showing His faithfulness to the promise (Genesis 25:21). Now, carrying twins, she feels them jostling inside her and becomes deeply troubled - so much so that she seeks the Lord directly. Her question, 'If this is how it is, why am I like this?' reveals her confusion and pain, but also her trust in God to give meaning to her suffering.

God’s response is striking: two nations are in her womb, and the older will serve the younger - a reversal of every cultural expectation. This sets the stage for the rivalry between Jacob and Esau, showing that God’s choices are based on His purpose, not human tradition.

The Divine Oracle and the Reversal of Human Expectations

The prophecy given to Rebekah - 'Two nations are in your womb, and two peoples from within you shall be divided; the one shall be stronger than the other, the older shall serve the younger' - is a divine declaration that redefines how God works through human history.

In the ancient world, the firstborn son held a special place - he inherited the family's blessing, leadership, and covenant promises. So when God says the older will serve the younger, He overturns a foundational social and religious norm. The Hebrew verb 'yaʿavod' (shall serve) carries weight. It is the same word used for slavery and worship, indicating a spiritual ordering beyond political dominance. This moment sets a pattern seen later in God’s choices: David over his brothers, Moses over Aaron in leadership, and ultimately Jesus, the younger 'son' in David’s line, who fulfills the promise. It shows that God’s election isn’t based on birth order or human merit, but on His sovereign purpose.

The phrase 'two nations' points beyond Jacob and Esau as individuals to the larger peoples they will become - Israel and Edom. Scripture later confirms this: in Numbers 20:14-16, Moses refers to Edom as 'my brother,' showing the familial tie behind national conflicts. Malachi 1:2-3 echoes this oracle, saying, 'I loved Jacob but I hated Esau,' not as personal favoritism but as a reflection of how each nation responded to God over time. The division begins in the womb but unfolds through generations of choice and consequence.

God’s choice of the younger over the older wasn’t just about two brothers - it was about how God builds His kingdom through unexpected people.

This divine word to Rebekah is one of the clearest early examples of God revealing His plan before birth. It prepares us for other prenatal callings, like Jeremiah, whom God says He 'knew before I formed you in the womb' (Jeremiah 1:5). God shaped Jacob’s destiny before he took his first breath, and He shapes our stories with purpose and care.

God's Answer in the Midst of Struggle and the Shock of Reversed Expectations

This moment with Rebekah shows that God doesn't stay distant when life feels chaotic, but draws near to those who seek Him, even as He upends what the world considers normal.

Rebekah was in pain and perplexed by the turmoil inside her, yet she turned to the Lord - and He answered with clarity and purpose. The idea that the older would serve the younger flew in the face of every cultural norm, where the firstborn held the highest honor and inheritance, but God was showing that His kingdom doesn't run on human rules.

Even in the confusion of pregnancy, God speaks clearly - not to confirm tradition, but to reveal His surprising plan.

Later, the apostle Paul refers to this very moment in Romans 9:10-12, saying, 'Though they were not yet born and had done nothing either good or bad - in order that God’s purpose of election might continue, not because of works but because of him who calls - it was said to her, “The older will serve the younger.”' This reminds us that God’s choices are rooted in His mercy, not human merit, and prepares us to see how He works through unlikely people to bring about His promises.

God's Electing Love: From Jacob and Esau to Christ and the Church

This divine reversal - choosing the younger over the older - finds its fullest meaning when the apostle Paul draws directly from this story to explain God’s sovereign grace in Christ.

Paul writes in Romans 9:10-13, 'Though they were not yet born and had done nothing either good or bad - in order that God’s purpose of election might continue, not because of works but because of him who calls - it was said to her, “The older will serve the younger.” As it is written, “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.”' Paul isn’t talking about personal salvation based on fate, but about God’s sovereign right to choose the line through which the Messiah would come - choosing Jacob not because he was better, but because God’s redemptive plan moves through calling, not human merit.

This phrase 'Jacob I loved, Esau I hated' comes from Malachi 1:2-3, where God says to Israel, 'I have loved you,’ says the Lord. But you say, ‘How have you loved us?’ ‘Is not Esau Jacob’s brother?’ declares the Lord. ‘Yet I have loved Jacob but Esau I have hated.’' In context, this isn’t about individual destiny but national roles - Edom (Esau) became a symbol of opposition to God’s people, while Israel (Jacob) was chosen to carry the promise. Yet even here, God’s 'hating' Esau means rejecting his nation’s claim to the covenant, not eternal condemnation. The point is that God’s promises depend on His faithfulness, not human status.

This pattern - God choosing the younger, the overlooked, the weak - points forward to Jesus, who, though born in humility and entering the world as a servant, is the true heir of all God’s promises. Jacob, the younger, carried the line of blessing. Jesus, the 'younger' as a suffering servant, fulfills what Jacob only foreshadowed. He is the one through whom all nations are blessed, not by birthright, but by grace through faith.

God’s choice of Jacob over Esau wasn’t about personal favoritism - it was a divine preview of how He would build His kingdom through the unexpected, culminating in Jesus, the true younger Son.

So this story doesn’t end with twins in a womb or even with two warring nations - it points to the cross, where God’s electing love reaches its climax in Christ, who calls not the deserving, but those He loves by grace. And that same grace invites us, like Rebekah, to bring our confusion to God, trusting that His purposes are good, even when they surprise us.

Application