Wisdom

Understanding Ecclesiastes 6: Wealth Without Enjoyment Is Vanity


Chapter Summary

Ecclesiastes 6 explores a painful paradox: what good are God's gifts if He doesn't also grant the ability to enjoy them? The Teacher presents the bleak picture of a person who has everything - wealth, honor, a large family, and a long life - yet finds no satisfaction. This chapter serves as a stark warning against placing our hope in earthly treasures, showing that a full life is not measured by what we accumulate but by our capacity for contentment.

Core Passages from Ecclesiastes 6

  • Ecclesiastes 6:2a man to whom God gives wealth, possessions, and honor, so that he lacks nothing of all that he desires, yet God does not give him power to enjoy them, but a stranger enjoys them. This is vanity; it is a grievous evil.

    This verse captures the chapter's central tragedy: a person blessed with everything imaginable but cursed with an inability to find happiness in it, ultimately leaving it all for someone else.
  • Ecclesiastes 6:7All the toil of man is for his mouth, yet his appetite is not satisfied.

    Here, the Teacher observes that all our work is to feed ourselves. Our deeper hunger for meaning and satisfaction is never truly filled, highlighting the endless cycle of human striving.
  • Ecclesiastes 6:12For who knows what is good for man while he lives the few days of his vain life, which he passes like a shadow? For who can tell man what will be after him under the sun?

    The chapter concludes with a humbling question that exposes our limitations. We don't know what is truly good for us in our short lives, nor can we know the future.
True fulfillment transcends material possessions and longevity, residing instead in the God-given capacity for contentment.
True fulfillment transcends material possessions and longevity, residing instead in the God-given capacity for contentment.

Historical & Cultural Context

The Paradox of the Unfulfilled Millionaire

Continuing his observations 'under the sun,' the Teacher shifts from a general discussion of wealth in chapter 5 to a specific, heartbreaking scenario. He paints a picture of a man who has achieved the pinnacle of worldly success - possessions, wealth, and honor - only to reveal a deep, internal emptiness. This is not a story of misfortune where wealth is lost. It is a story of a spiritual inability to enjoy what one already has, a problem the Teacher calls a 'grievous evil.'

The Emptiness of a Long, Unsatisfied Life

The Teacher then broadens his argument beyond money. He imagines a man with a hundred children and an incredibly long life, two of the highest cultural blessings of his time. Yet, even these are declared meaningless if the man's 'soul is not satisfied with life's good things.' The chapter ends with great uncertainty, questioning humanity's ability to discern what is truly good or to know what the future holds, leaving the reader to ponder the limits of human wisdom.

The pursuit of fleeting earthly pleasures ultimately leads to an unfillable void.
The pursuit of fleeting earthly pleasures ultimately leads to an unfillable void.

Anatomy of Dissatisfaction

In this chapter, the Teacher acts like a physician diagnosing a spiritual sickness that afflicts humanity. He moves from one symptom to another, exposing the futility of a life rich in possessions but poor in joy. The scene is not a specific location but a universal observation of the human condition, examining why the things we chase often fail to bring the happiness we expect.

The Gift You Can't Enjoy  (Ecclesiastes 6:1-2)

1 There is an evil that I have seen under the sun, and it lies heavy on mankind:
2 a man to whom God gives wealth, possessions, and honor, so that he lacks nothing of all that he desires, yet God does not give him power to enjoy them, but a stranger enjoys them. This is vanity; it is a grievous evil.

Commentary:

Having everything but being unable to enjoy it is a deep and painful tragedy.

The Teacher opens with a heavy heart, describing a common and painful problem he's seen. It's the case of someone God has blessed with immense wealth, possessions, and honor - everything a person could wish for. But there's a tragic catch: God does not give this person the 'power to enjoy them.' Instead, a stranger ends up benefiting from it all. This is not bad luck. The Teacher calls it 'vanity' and a 'grievous evil.' The real tragedy isn't the lack of things, but the lack of ability to find joy in them. It highlights a crucial truth: possessions and the enjoyment of those possessions are two separate gifts.

A Long Life Isn't Always a Good Life  (Ecclesiastes 6:3-6)

3 If a man fathers a hundred children and lives many years, so that the days of his years are many, but his soul is not satisfied with life's good things, and he also has no burial, I say that a stillborn child is better off than he.
4 for it comes in vanity and goes in darkness, and in darkness its name is covered.
5 It has not seen the sun or known anything, yet it finds rest rather than he.
6 Even though he should live a thousand years twice over, yet enjoy no good - do not all go to the one place?

Commentary:

A long, prosperous life without inner satisfaction is more tragic than a life that never began.

To make his point even more shocking, the Teacher presents another example. Imagine a man who has a hundred children and lives for two thousand years - the ultimate picture of success and blessing in the ancient world. Yet, if his soul is never satisfied and he dies without honor (symbolized by 'no burial'), his life is meaningless. In a stunning comparison, the Teacher says a stillborn child is better off. Though the child never saw the sun or had a name, it found rest. The man, despite his long and seemingly full life, never did. This powerfully argues that the quality of life, measured by satisfaction, is far more important than its quantity.

The Never-Ending Treadmill of Desire  (Ecclesiastes 6:7-9)

7 All the toil of man is for his mouth, yet his appetite is not satisfied.
8 For what advantage has the wise man over the fool? And what does the poor man have who knows how to conduct himself before the living?
9 Better is the sight of the eyes than the wandering of the appetite: this also is vanity and a striving after wind.

Commentary:

Our work may fill our stomachs, but it can never satisfy our souls, so it's wiser to enjoy what we have than to always crave more.

Here, the Teacher explains why we're often so dissatisfied. He says, 'All the toil of man is for his mouth, yet his appetite is not satisfied.' We work tirelessly to feed our physical needs and desires, but our inner hunger, our soul's appetite, always wants more. There's no ultimate advantage for the wise over the fool in this regard, as both struggle with this constant craving. The Teacher then offers a piece of practical wisdom: 'Better is the sight of the eyes than the wandering of the appetite.' In other words, it's better to enjoy what you have right in front of you than to be constantly chasing fantasies and desires you don't have. To do otherwise is 'striving after wind.'

Humanity's Great Unknowns  (Ecclesiastes 6:10-12)

10 Whatever has come to be has already been named, and it is known what man is, and that he is not able to dispute with one stronger than he.
11 The more words, the more vanity, and what is the advantage to man?
12 For who knows what is good for man while he lives the few days of his vain life, which he passes like a shadow? For who can tell man what will be after him under the sun?

Commentary:

We are finite and cannot control our destiny or even know what is truly good for us, making much of our striving pointless.

The chapter concludes by zooming out to the biggest questions of all. The Teacher reminds us that our nature and destiny are already established. We are human, and we can't argue with God, who is stronger than we are. Trying to find answers through endless talk ('the more words, the more vanity') is useless. The final verses leave us with two humbling, unanswered questions. First, who can possibly know what is truly good for us during our short, shadow-like lives? And second, who can tell us what will happen on earth after we're gone? This ending emphasizes our significant limitations and points to the futility of trying to find ultimate meaning and control on our own terms.

The Heart of the Matter

The Emptiness of Materialism

Ecclesiastes 6 powerfully demonstrates that wealth, status, and possessions have no built-in power to bring happiness. The chapter separates the having from the enjoying, showing that a life dedicated to accumulation can still be deeply empty and meaningless.

Contentment as a Divine Gift

The ability to enjoy life's blessings is presented not as a natural result of having them, but as a separate gift from God. This theme challenges the idea that we can manufacture our own happiness, suggesting instead that true satisfaction is something we must receive from a source outside ourselves.

The Limits of Human Wisdom and Control

The chapter concludes by emphasizing how little we actually know and control. We cannot change our fundamental nature, argue with God's sovereign plan, or know what is ultimately best for us. This theme serves to humble us, pushing us away from self-reliance and toward dependence on God.

The pursuit of understanding in the face of the infinite universe leads to humility and awe.
The pursuit of understanding in the face of the infinite universe leads to humility and awe.

Bringing Wisdom into Your World

How does this chapter challenge modern ideas of 'the good life'?

This chapter directly confronts the modern belief that success is measured by wealth, achievements, and experiences. Ecclesiastes 6:2 shows that you can have all of these things and still be miserable. It encourages you to redefine 'the good life' not by what you own, but by your capacity for gratitude and joy in what God has already given you.

What does it mean to live by the 'sight of the eyes' instead of the 'wandering of the appetite'?

Living by the 'sight of the eyes' means finding contentment in your present reality - your family, your job, your home, the simple blessings right in front of you (Ecclesiastes 6:9). The 'wandering of the appetite' is the restless, modern urge to always want more - the next upgrade, the better vacation, the different life you see on social media. This verse calls you to practice gratitude for what is, rather than anxiety for what isn't.

If we can't know what's truly 'good' for us, how should we live?

The final verses (Ecclesiastes 6:12) are not a call to despair, but to humility. Since you cannot control the future or know all the answers, you are freed from the pressure of having to figure it all out. It invites you to live with trust in God, focusing on walking faithfully and enjoying the simple gifts of each day, leaving the ultimate outcomes in His hands.

The Emptiness of a Full Hand

Ecclesiastes 6 delivers a sobering message: a life overflowing with the world's goods can be deeply empty. The Teacher shows that satisfaction is not a guaranteed result of success, but a separate, precious gift from God. The ultimate point is that our restless striving for more is a chase after wind, because true contentment can't be earned or owned. This chapter forces us to look past our possessions and ambitions to ask a deeper question: what truly satisfies the human soul?

What This Means for Us Today

Ecclesiastes 6 doesn't offer a simple solution, but an invitation to honesty. It invites us to admit our limitations and confess that our definitions of success are often hollow. The chapter calls us to stop chasing the wind and instead turn to God, the only one who can grant the gift of a truly satisfied heart.

  • What blessing in your life do you need to ask God for the power to truly enjoy?
  • Where are you striving for more when God is calling you to be content with what you have?
  • How can you practice gratitude today for the simple 'sight of your eyes'?
True fulfillment is found not in the fleeting accumulation of worldly possessions, but in recognizing the vanity of earthly pursuits and embracing a higher purpose.
True fulfillment is found not in the fleeting accumulation of worldly possessions, but in recognizing the vanity of earthly pursuits and embracing a higher purpose.

Further Reading

Immediate Context

This chapter sets the stage by discussing the vanity of riches and the dangers of loving money, leading directly into chapter 6's example of unenjoyed wealth.

After concluding that we cannot know what is good, this chapter offers a series of practical proverbs on how to live wisely in a frustrating and unpredictable world.

Connections Across Scripture

Jesus' parable of the rich fool perfectly illustrates Ecclesiastes 6, telling of a man who stored up great wealth for himself but was not 'rich toward God' and lost it all in an instant.

Paul echoes the Teacher's wisdom, stating that 'godliness with contentment is great gain' and warning that the love of money leads to ruin.

This psalm reflects on the foolishness of trusting in wealth, reminding the reader that 'man in his pomp will not remain; he is like the beasts that perish.'

Discussion Questions

  • In what areas of your life do you most often experience the 'wandering of the appetite' (Ecclesiastes 6:9)? What helps you focus on the 'sight of the eyes' and be content?
  • The Teacher says a stillborn child is better off than a man with a long, prosperous, but unsatisfied life (Ecclesiastes 6:3-5). Why do you think he makes such a shocking statement, and what does it teach us about what God values?
  • The chapter ends by saying we can't know what is truly good for us (Ecclesiastes 6:12). How can this truth be freeing rather than frightening in your daily walk with God?

Glossary